Writing that documents time spent at the Bethlem Museum of the Mind archives studying 19th-century psychiatric records. My research is to inform a collaborative quilting piece that weaves together past and present realities of medical misogyny.
The work is an Unlimited UK Open Award 2026 commission made possible thanks to funding from Arts Council England.
September 2026
Muse and Metaphor.
Meet Frances, a widow committed to Croydon Mental Hospital in August 1910 at the age of 63, the same age as me. This is not the first time Frances was admitted to an asylum. Nor is this the only photograph of her, but this is the photograph that screams agency to me, in spite of and because of the emotions one can read between the lines of this powerful pose.
Frances. Photo used by permission of Bethlem Museum of the Mind
There are 7 records for Frances in the Bethlem Hospital Patient Admission Registers and Casebooks held on Find My Past, relating to three asylum admissions.
Frances is admitted to Bethlem in 1880 for the first time. The recorded information reveals she has four children, with the youngest being 7 months old at the time of admission, and she is 33 years old, although the “Age on first Attack” is listed as 31. The “Form of Mental Disorder” is listed as “Acute mania with restless excitement” and the “Supposed Cause of Insanity” is “Death of Sister-in-law”.
The language used in the pre-printed Proforma questionnaires of the Bethlem Admission books hark of Daisy Lafarge’s exploration of the militarisation of medical language in her book Lovebug, but what are the pathogens of mental illness? I keep finding myself trying to jump the divide between the information in these books and how causality is arrived at from the contemporary questionnaires used by mental health practitioners to determine one’s rights to treatment – “on a scale of 1 to 10 with 10 being the most …”
In 1887 Frances is admitted to Bethlem for the second time. She is recorded as being a housewife of 40 years of age. She was described as “…incoherent, has hallucinations of smell and believes she has suffered from blood poison. Excessively garrulous. Believes her husband’s hand is in her inside and that she has been persecuted all her life.”
When admitting her to the asylum, under the section “Other facts (if any) indicating Insanity communicated to me by others”, the admitting doctor writes that her husband Albert, a butcher, describes that “… she behaves at times indecently and strips herself and that she is very sleepless and restless at night.”
Her catamenia is noted as being “irregular”, and she experiences “Bad smells. Has been disinfecting house”. Under the heading “Common sensibility” it is recorded that she has “flushes of heat and cold”.
Anyone reading this today, would recognise Frances’s irregular periods and flushes to be indicative of perimenopause or the menopause.
Frances is described as “A tall fat woman dark hair light grey eyes dirty complexion. Sits with her handkerchief to her mouth saying she is going to spit up blood.”
March 21st she is “noisy and violent and confined to her room in strong clothing.” A week later there is “no change. Noisy violent tearing her clothes and generally troublesome”.
May 22nd her condition is “unchanged. Head shaved ordered to be blistered with cotton liniment.” I am appalled. Frances is subjected to what was in the 1880s a common medical treatment to apply caustic substances to the body to create blisters that would allow “bad humours” to escape. Where’s my sertraline? And a Valium for good measure.
June 22nd “No change. Blister had little effect on the mental condition.”
July 12th “No change. Rubs all sorts of dirt into her skin. Has been having shower baths with little effect.”
July 17th “ordered Paraldehyde every night”, this an anti-epileptic drug in the same group as cannabidiols. Pass the THC.
July 30th “Has for the last fortnight been having continuous baths. She is now kept in the bath for about 10 hours a day. Very little effect. Is menstruating and Bath stopped.
September 11th “No change. Dirty and abusive. Tears up her clothing. Has got much thinner than on her admission.” And finally on 22nd February she is “Discharged uncured.”
And now it is 17th August 1910 and Frances is 63 and admitted to the Croydon Mental Hospital for her final cure. Her insanity is recorded as being caused by “Mental Stress (sudden)” and the predisposing cause of her insanity was “Death of Husband”. She was a private patient, and was able to afford an asylum before the National Health Service existed.
Under the title “(a) Facts indicating Insanity observed by myself at time of examination viz.: -“, Frances is manic.”… she told me that she was dead and to confirm this gave me a packet of letters which she said were letters of condolence. She says that her children and nurses and others are plotting against her. Told me a few days ago that she had great powers over things and that she could change plants to animals and had done so. That she sometimes planted bits of animals (e.g. a rabbit’s head) in order to get them to grow up into animals.
A 2nd doctor (H.O.Smith) agreeing to her admission “Frances states that her daughter is her husband’s sister-in-law. That the Croydon Corporation Officials have arranged for her to set her house on fire and that it is to take place on Tuesday. That she has been brutally assaulted by her sons who knocked fourteen of her teeth out. That she has had sewage to eat where she has been staying and that her jewellery (rings) she put into the water closet was sent to Dr. Baker who had a special pipe to his house so that he could receive them. That she passed by rectum a small fish that was alive. “That she has been dead and come to life again”, “That all women are hoares.””
On July 17th 1911, nearly a year after admission, Frances is discharged for a final time and collected by her son, the petitioner.
Atrabilious to her mania, I am discovering the lives of the women patients recorded in the case books at the Bethlem Museum of the Mind. Unearthing medical misogynies and examining the use of language to describe ill health is part of my Unlimited commission that will inform an exhibition and a series of workshops at the Bethlem Gallery early in 2027.
Notes
Fairly early on, I decided to look at the case books from the late 1800s to early 1900s as the hand writing in these books is more easily decipherable, and data protection restricts more contemporary record explorations.